HomeCourt of Justice case law → C-257/14
C-257/142015van der Lans Ruled for the passenger

A sudden breakdown is no excuse either

Technical problems arising unexpectedly, not attributable to poor maintenance and not detected during routine checks, still do not qualify as extraordinary circumstances. The Court reasons that breakdowns are inherent in air transport and the carrier, not the passenger, bears that risk.

Why it matters: The answer "the fault appeared unexpectedly, we could not foresee it" is not a lawful ground for refusal.

These summaries are provided for understanding and do not replace legal advice. Full texts are available in the EUR-Lex database by case number.

Check your flight in a minute
Open the calculator
File a claim in 3 minutes

The fee is deducted only from the compensation recovered. No payout — no fee.

← All rulings C-402/07 · Sturgeon C-549/07 · Wallentin-Hermann C-452/13 · Germanwings C-11/11 · Folkerts C-195/17 · Krüsemann C-315/15 · Pešková and Peška